As a lawyer, Jiang Haochen certainly knew that there were so many assets involved, and it was impossible to deny that Xia Xiting was not starting a joint venture with Yao Yanxu just by relying on such a small amount of evidence.
Jiang Haochen continued:"President, during the trial, the chat records from many years ago are indeed not convincing enough."
"But there is something wrong with what Lawyer Cheng just said. That is, Ms. Xia and Mr. Yao were not in an ambiguous period at that time. Jiang
Haochen looked at Miao Qinghe and Li Weitong again:"Ms. Miao, Ms. Li, Ms. Xia should have liked the person she had an extramarital affair with, Mr. Ruan Qisheng, right?""
"Yes. Back then in school, Xiting had a crush on Ruan Qisheng, and the two even briefly stayed together for more than half a year."
"Later, due to Ruan Qisheng's excellent grades and receiving a full scholarship from a prestigious foreign university, and the opportunity to go abroad, the two broke up by default."
Li Weitong continued Miao Qinghe's words and added:"After graduation, although Xi Ting was single, Xi Ting probably did not like Yao Yanxu. At that time, Yao Yanxu simply liked Xi Ting."
"Xiting knew that Yao Yanxu liked her, but Yao Yanxu had a good personality and was very kind to her, so she treated Yao Yanxu as a good friend."
"According to current terminology, it is a spare tire."
When he heard this, Yao Yanxu's expression was ugly.
Yao Yanxu's expression was ugly not because Miao Qinghe and Li Weitong said that he was a spare tire, but because at that time Yao Yanxu really thought that Xia Xiting and himself were in an ambiguous period.
Especially since he was unemployed. Xia Xiting was still willing to lend her money to start her own business. She always thought it was true love, but it turned out to be just a spare tire.
It turned out that the clown was herself.
Jiang Haochen looked at Xia Xiting:"Ms. Xia, do you agree with this statement?"
"I don’t agree. I told Miao Qinghe and Li Weitong that way just because I was embarrassed to admit it."
"After Ruan Qisheng and I broke up, I was disheartened by him. Jiang Haochen immediately asked,"
Really?" you sure?"
Jiang Haochen specifically asked Xia Xiting if she was sure, and Xia Xiting was a little hesitant. Xia Xiting looked at Cheng Taihua, and Cheng Taihua could only nod at Xia Xiting, asking Xia Xiting to give a positive answer.
Because if you don't give a positive answer at this time, it will definitely not work..
Otherwise, it would be okay if you deny what you just said.
Xia Xiting replied to Jiang Haochen:"If I didn't have a good impression of Yanxu at that time, how could I lend him money to start a business? Jiang
Haochen immediately smiled:"Presiding judge, during the trial, I will confirm it with Ms. Xia in front of you again.""
"Ms. Xia, please answer me again in front of the presiding judge and the court."
"Did you really give money to Mr. Yao to invest in a business together because you were frustrated with your ex-boyfriend, had a crush on Mr. Yao, and were in an ambiguous period? Xia
Xiting was very panicked, but she still answered bravely:"That's right.""
"Presiding judge, during the trial, I found that Ms. Xia is really a liar. Let's take a look at the new evidence"
"This chat record of mine is between Ms. Xia and her extramarital affair partner Mr. Ruan."
"This chat record can not only prove that Ms. Xia does not like Mr. Yao, but has lingering feelings for Mr. Ruan, it can also prove that the 20,000 yuan that Ms. Xia gave Mr. Yao was a loan."
"Of course, this chat record was saved by video by Mr. Ruan’s ex-girlfriend abroad."
"By the way, Mr. Ruan only broke up with his girlfriend when Ms. Xia and Mr. Yao were in divorce proceedings."
With that said, Zhou Ruoyao connected Jiang Haochen's mobile phone to the screen.
An original video was displayed.
Zhou Ruoyao stretched the video to the required length.
When she saw the chat record, Xia Xiting's expression darkened. The chat record is dated not long after Xia Xiting lent money to Yao Yanxu.
The specific chat content is as follows
【Ruan Qisheng】:【If you lend money to Yao Yanxu, you won't like Yao Yanxu, right?】
【Xia Xiting】:【Of course I don't like Yao Yanxu anymore, I like you, and it's not like you don't know it, but you ended up studying abroad. (angry expression)】
【Ruan Qisheng】:【There is no way I can go abroad. If you don't like Yao Yanxu, go and get your money back】
【Xia Xiting】:【That's not good? They all said they lent it to him.】
【Ruan Qisheng】:【Then aren't you afraid that I will be angry?】
【Xia Xiting】:【But I agreed to lend it to him, and now I can’t open my mouth when I take it back.】
【Ruan Qisheng】:【Then I'm angry】
【Xia Xiting】:【Don't be angry. I'll find a chance later.】
【Xia Xiting】:【Why don't you speak?】
【Xia Xiting】:【Don't ignore me】
【Xia Xiting】:【I'll ask him to take it back in a few days. Is that okay? 】
However, at this time, Ruan Qisheng was obviously angry and did not reply to Xia Xiting.
Three days later, Xia Xiting sent a message to Ruan Qisheng, but still received no reply.
On the fifth day
【Xia Xiting】:【I have asked Yao Yanxu to get the money back】
【Ruan Qisheng】:【That's pretty much it. But are you sure you're not lying to me?】
【Xia Xiting】:【Of course I didn't lie to you. He and I are already clean, so don't be angry.】
【Ruan Qisheng】:【Then you transfer the money and I'll keep it for you. I'll give it back to you when you need it, so that you don't have to do a superficial job with me.】
【Xia Xiting】:【20,000 transfer】
【Xia Xiting】:【Is the head office ready now?】
【Ruan Qisheng】:【Be good, this is my baby. ]
Seeing this, Yao Yanxu clenched his fists and was extremely angry.
Yao Yanxu said:"I remembered that back then you said that your grandma was sick and you deducted 20,000 from the account. It turned out that it was for Ruan Qisheng, this rubbish."
Xia Xiting was speechless.
Cheng Taihua panicked at this time:"It's over, the situation is not good now."
If it is really confirmed that this is a loan, it will directly become a headwind situation.
Jiang Haochen could find so much evidence, but Cheng Taihua had no confidence in turning the headwind situation into a tailwind situation.
Jiang Haochen said again:"President, the court heard that I believe it can be confirmed from the chat records above that this is a loan, and Ms. Xia had already found an excuse to take it back."
"Even if it was a share purchase at the time and they took away the 20,000 yuan, Ms. Xia and Mr. Ruan said that they were settled with Mr. Yao, so they were withdrawing their shares, right?"
"However, after Ms. Xia and our client got together later, our client became deeply in love, so we did not dwell on these matters."
Hearing Jiang Haochen say that he was deeply in love, Yao Yanxu knew that Jiang Haochen was trying to save face for himself.
Because isn't this just dog licking?
However, the most depressing thing is that he is Xia Xiting's dog licking, and Xia Xiting is Ruan Qisheng's dog licking.
Yao Yanxu feels too much Insulted.
Jiang Haochen continued to look at Xia Xiting:"Ms. Xia, can you say that my chat history is fake?"
"If you dare to say it is fake, then do you dare to compare the chat history on your mobile phone?"
But how dare Xia Xiting?
Xia Xiting could only look to Cheng Taihua for help.
Cheng Taihua was helpless.
According to this chat record, Xia Xiting's chatting attitude was like licking a dog.
It doesn't make sense to say that she doesn't like Ruan Qisheng.
Even if Cheng Taihua is at this time If you continue to insist that Xia Xiting likes Yao Yanxu, the presiding judge and the court will not believe it.
The most important thing is, as Jiang Haochen said, if the 20,000 yuan is taken back, even the money invested in the shares is equivalent to withdrawing the shares.
So these shares It is pre-marital property, and at most the increase in value after marriage is calculated.
This is very fatal.
Cheng Taihua did not expect that such a small detail could be overturned by Jiang Haochen.
The presiding judge looked at Cheng Taihua and Xia Xiting:"Does the defendant have anything to explain? ?"
Seeing that Cheng Taihua and Xia Xiting were silent, the presiding judge said again:"If the defendant has nothing to say, then this court will adopt this statement."
Cheng Taihua and Xia Xiting were silent again, and the presiding judge said:"Plaintiff, this court will accept this testimony."
"Do you have anything to add?"
"Of course there is."
Jiang Haochen smiled lightly, knowing that he was more than half successful.
"If the pre-marital property is clear and all the factory equity belongs to our agent, then the couple’s property will only cover the increase in the five years of marriage, plus cash, real estate, and some stocks invested, totaling a little over 5 billion. I Just think of it as five billion"
"The presiding judge, the court hearing, in fact, a considerable amount of property was transferred by Ms. Xia"
"Let’s first talk about Ms. Xia’s transfer to Mr. Ruan."
"This chat record shows that every time Ms. Xia transfers money to Mr. Ruan abroad, Mr. Ruan is notified."
"I counted the chat records and found that Ms. Xia has transferred a total of 28 million in cash to Mr. Ruan over the years.
Xia Xiting and Cheng Taihua had said this, and Cheng Taihua was prepared. Cheng Taihua immediately retorted:"Presiding Judge, this is a loan. The chat record clearly stated that this is a loan."
Jiang Haochen added:"But I've never paid it back, right?" Cheng
Taihua defended Xia Xiting by insisting that it was a loan."Even if it is not repaid, it is still a loan. If you have money, you will naturally pay it back.""
Yao Yanxu's lungs are about to burst with anger at this time.
He has actually indirectly supported Ruan Qisheng for so many years. (To read Baoshuang novels, go to Feilu Novel Network!)
28 million, living a cool life
"Chief Judge, Mr. Ruan is now opening a restaurant abroad and has a lot of debt."
"For people who have no ability to repay, it is unrealistic to borrow so much money."
"Moreover, Mr. Ruan was also the object of Ms. Xia's extramarital affair, and Mr. Yao, the party concerned, was completely unaware of it. This was a transfer of assets.
Cheng Taihua retorted again:"Didn't Mr. Yao borrow the money?" Does Ms. Qian Xia know everything?"
"As far as I know, Mr. Yao lent at least one million to his friends. Mr. Yao, is this a fact?
Jiang Haochen said again:"Presiding judge, during the trial, we can look at the chat records again.""
Zhou Ruoyao immediately switched the chat history to where Jiang Haochen needed it.
This is the chat history from June 2018.
【Ruan Qisheng】:【Xiting, I hope you will get better and better in the future. I hope we will miss you like this again in the future. Farewell.】
【Xia Xiting】:【What’s wrong with you? Why do you suddenly say such things?】
【Ruan Qisheng】:【I opened a fast food restaurant, I can't keep running it, I owe a lot of money, my life is over】
【Xia Xiting】:【You haven't done anything in the past two years. Are you running a restaurant? ]
Because as you can see from the chat records above, since Xia Xiting transferred 20,000 yuan to Ruan Qisheng in October 2015, there have not been many chats since then.
In March 2016, Xia Xiting approached Ruan Qisheng, but she never received a reply. The equivalent of 20,000 yuan was spent directly on Ruan Qisheng.
After more than two years, Ruan Qisheng took the initiative to send a message to Xia Xiting.
At this time, Xia Xiting and Yao Yanxu were already lovers because there was no news from Ruan Qisheng in the past two years.
After all, after being ignored by the male god for two years, the licking dog will naturally become a positive person.
Not to mention that the career of dog licker Yao Yanxu was booming at that time.[]
【Ruan Qisheng】:【I want to start my own business, be more successful than Yao Yanxu, and win you back】
【Xia Xiting】:【Don't say that, we've already missed it】
【Ruan Qisheng】:【Yes, I have missed it forever. I hope you will live happily in the future, and I hope I can stay in your heart forever. Farewell.】
【Xia Xiting】:【Don't worry about it. If you owe some money, you won't commit suicide.】
【Ruan Qisheng】:【I owe five million, and I can't pay it back.】
【Xia Xiting】:【There's nothing I can do about this amount of money, but I can help you raise 1 million first. You give back part of it first, and I'll help you find a way later. 】
Because Yao Yanxu and Xia Xiting were not married at that time, Xia Xiting could not get much money.
What follows is Ruan Qisheng's thanks to Xia Xiting, and Xia Xiting's heart-warming words to comfort Ruan Qisheng.
After that, Zhou Ruoyao switched the chat history to the records related to each subsequent time Xia Xiting sent money to Ruan Qisheng.
After showing the chat history, Jiang Haochen said:"Presiding judge, every time in the trial, the other party is always miserable. Ms. Xia took the initiative and offered to give him the money. Mr. Ruan finally said that he borrowed it and would pay it back when he had the money."
"If lending to an extramarital affair partner is the same as lending to a friend, then in the future, when transferring assets during a marital affair, it is better to lend to the affair partner."
"Therefore, I strongly disagree with what Attorney Cheng just said.
The presiding judge discussed it with the collegial panel and said:"The objection is valid.""
Seeing that the presiding judge agreed with Jiang Haochen, Cheng Taihua began to sweat on his forehead.
"Is Lawyer Jiang too sharp?"
"Is this too strong?"
Chen Muen and Zhao Chuyi were speechless at this time.
They have been Cheng Taihua's lawyers for so long, and they have never seen Cheng Taihua fight so passively in any lawsuit.
Even if he is defending the wrong party, Cheng Taihua can tell There were a lot of rebuttals.
But Jiang Haochen's opinions were all supported by ironclad evidence. This made Cheng Taihua, who had always been eloquent, dumb and unable to speak out.
So Jiang Haochen was really a bit strong.
Yao Yanxu was already angry at this time. It exploded.
If he hadn't seen the chat records here, Yao Yanxu would never have imagined that Xia Xiting would be so humble.
He is really the clown among clowns.
However, Jiang Haochen's evidence is certainly not as simple as this.
Jiang Haochen continued:"I'll say it again Let’s talk about Ms. Xia’s other asset transfer behaviors"
"Ms. Xia was in charge of family investment. During the five and a half years she was married to Mr. Yao, she invested in a total of ten factories, all of which were eventually sold."
"After my investigation, I found that these factories were finally bought by several buyers. The company behind these buyers is a company in Mancai Island abroad."
"The final actual shareholders of these overseas companies in Mancai Island are Ms. Xia’s three brothers."
"Ms. Xia achieved the purpose of transferring assets by causing the factory to cause book losses, devaluing the factory and selling it at a low price."
"The amount of assets transferred reached 500 million"
"Now, after these factories changed their names, they continued to cooperate with Mr. Yao's factory, which was kept in the dark, and became suppliers. They have made at least 300 million in profits over the years."
"If it had not been sold, the 300 million should belong to the profits of the parent company."
Hearing this, Yao Yanxu stared at Xia Xiting. He didn't expect that he trusted Xia Xiting so much, and Xia Xiting actually used financial means to transfer assets abroad.
"Can he check this?"
Cheng Taihua, Xia Xiting, Chen Muen, and Zhao Chuyi were stunned. Did they feel that Jiang Haochen's investigative ability was a little outrageous?
From the moment Jiang Haochen started defending until now, the initiative has all been on Jiang Haochen's side, and he has been directly crushed. Originally,
Cheng Taihua still had He wanted Jiang Haochen to be unable to face him.
But now, Cheng Taihua felt that he really couldn't face Jiang Haochen.
You'll Also Like
-
A noble son from a poor family
Chapter 81 290 days ago -
Entertainment: Take advantage of Tianxian’s youth and give her a boss’s license
Chapter 63 290 days ago -
I am Wen Zhong!
Chapter 54 290 days ago -
Industrial Survey: Are you a private enterprise engaged in black technology?
Chapter 52 290 days ago -
In the mixed martial arts adventure, all the heroines are broken
Chapter 61 290 days ago -
Let you write about a small character's counterattack, and you write about the Hongwu Emperor
Chapter 53 290 days ago -
Super God: Knock out Hua Ye and drag Kesha into the woods
Chapter 61 290 days ago -
Siheyuan: I, Qi Tongwei, started in 1980
Chapter 50 290 days ago -
Xuanxian Supreme
Chapter 190 290 days ago -
Siheyuan: I am a fool, and I show off to the audience
Chapter 53 290 days ago