If you are asked to popularize the law, will you sentence the judge to ten years?

Chapter 28: Zhang San’s admiration! Use the law to solve the trolley problem! 4/10

Ye Qiu finished speaking.

Zhang San couldn’t help but admire

"That’s so well said!"

"Lawyer Ye, if you have the chance, let’s communicate more!"

"I still have classes to attend today, so I won’t interrupt."

Zhang San really admires Ye Qiu.

Simple questions can analyze the deep meaning of the law.

Ye Qiu's research on the law is obviously very profound.

In addition, Zhang San thought secretly in his heart.

Today there are cases to torture those who student.

Then, Zhang San left the live broadcast room.

Seeing this scene, netizens were excited again

"my God! Teacher Zhang San was impressed by Lawyer Ye!"

"Such a handsome anchor! As expected of the man I am a fan of!"

"Fraudulent Lawyer Ye! Come here and even the honorary professor of Demonic Politics can educate you! too strong!"

"Six six six!!!"

At the same time, netizens also became excited.

"Lawyer Ye, let me give you a few more examples!"

"Let’s use the abstract Zhang San as an example!"

"Hahaha! Teacher Zhang San can’t just go back to the live broadcast room?! Ye

Qiu smiled after hearing this.

"I won’t give examples next."

"If you have anything to ask, just ask."

"Even Mai asked."

Ye Qiu opened the Wheat Linking session.

Netizens became excited and rushed to compete for the opportunity to get on the Wheat.

When Ye Qiu opened the Wheat Linking session, the first person to appear on the wheat was called Not the Little White Rabbit.

Bai Xiao Tu:"Hey, Lawyer Ye, it’s me again!

Ye Qiu:"Good morning, Xiaobai." Netizen:"

Shadow!" Lawyer Ye, you are unfair!"

"This is definitely a deliberate choice of young lady!"

"Ah! man!"

"But don’t mention it, it’s so cool to be able to listen to Miss White Rabbit’s voice!"

"Indeed, sound control benefits! Love begins today!"

"man! Hetui!!!"

"......."

Shadiao netizens are noisy.

Ye Qiu didn't care.

Just asked with a smile

"Xiaobai, is there any problem this time?"

Bai Xiaotu blinked his big eyes and then said

"That’s right, Lawyer Ye"

"It's if, I say if"

"Suppose that on a bifurcated railway, one person is tied up on one side and five people are tied up on the other."

"At this time, the tram will arrive soon and there is no way to stop it. I control the tram switch."

"In this urgent situation with no choice, I could only sacrifice one person to save five people."

"So, does my behavior count as an emergency?".........................................

Bai Xiaotu finished speaking.

Ye Qiu hasn't spoken yet.

Netizens started a heated discussion

"This is the classic trolley problem!"

"In the past, this was treated as a moral problem, but I didn’t expect that the young lady would ask about the legal aspect."

"Indeed, and this idea is quite reasonable. The tram is coming soon, which is very suitable for an emergency situation where there is no choice. It is similar to eating a panda or kicking a child. It can be regarded as an emergency escape, right?"

"I don’t think so! No matter how urgent you are to avoid danger, you can't decide a person's life, right?"

"But the value of five people is obviously greater than one. Do you want to let five people die for one person?"

"Who says that five people must be worth more than one person? What if that person is a top scientist and has just developed a 1nm lithography machine?"

"Good guy, why are you adding conditions? Aren't you going to make excuses? ?"

"Anyway, no matter what, it is definitely not easy to judge that the value of five people is greater than one person!"

"How else to judge? According to your logic, a single person can be the scientist who developed the photolithography machine. What if one of the five people has mastered nuclear fusion?"

"Damn it, why do you keep talking more and more outrageously? Aren't we talking about emergency evacuation?"

"yes! The young lady didn’t give so many conditions! Can we get back to the point?"

"I don’t think it’s necessary to be so arrogant. Just put yourself in their shoes. If that person were yourself, would you think the five people are bigger than you?"

"Damn it, when you say this, what else do you think?"

"You guys held back your words! Besides, I need to grow a brain!"

"Ahhhh! I can’t figure it out! I really can’t figure it out!"

"......"

"......"

Netizens on the barrage had their own opinions.

The debate was fierce.

Obviously the problem of the century is very lethal.

Logic from any angle.

They will all fall into a dead end............................................ but.

It's hard for Ye Qiu.

At this time, Ye Qiu smiled and spoke.

"Don't get too excited, everyone"

"Let me analyze this question."

"First of all, one thing is certain, what Xiaobai did is definitely not an emergency hedging."

"It does not meet the situation where there is no choice for emergency evacuation."

"Because you pressed the switch on your own initiative, and no one controlled you to control the direction of the tram through coercion or other threats."

"And more importantly"

"This is also the most critical point that everyone just discussed."

"That is"

"Are human rights to life equal?"

"about this point"

"It is clearly stipulated in our country’s laws"

"Everyone is equal and everyone has the same right to life"

"The right to life is irreplaceable and non-compensable."

"Therefore, no matter you are a high-ranking official or a beggar on the street, everyone's life is completely equal."

"On this basis, there is no situation where scientists have a higher right to life than ordinary people, and there is also no situation where five people have a higher right to life than one person."

"This is also the core principle of emergency evacuation judgment."

"That is: in the act of emergency avoidance, its protection and rescue interests"

"It must be greater than but not equal to or less than the benefit being sacrificed"

"That is to say"

"In order to survive, harm others, harm society, or even launch a nuclear bomb."

"These are illegal and criminal behaviors that are strictly prohibited by law and morally condemned."

Ye Qiu's words clearly resolved the dispute.

Netizens gradually came to their senses.

"What Lawyer Ye said makes sense!"

"I feel I understand a lot!"

"So it’s not an emergency, so what should I do?"............................................ at this time.

Bai Xiaotu also asked thoughtfully

"So Lawyer Ye, in fact, the solution to the tram problem"

"No one should be sacrificed at all, right?"

Ye Qiu nodded and continued.

"good"

"It is absolutely forbidden to sacrifice anyone to save your own life or the lives of others."

"Especially under our legal system in Daxia"

"Unless the individual himself has the consciousness of sacrifice"

"And without being guided or interfered with, he actively chose to sacrifice"

"Otherwise, no one can be sacrificed"

"Step into the Trolley Problem"

"If you are a single person who is tied up, and you choose to let the trolley hit you and save other people, this is okay."

"However, if someone else chooses to sacrifice you, or persuades you to sacrifice yourself, it is illegal."

"This is a crucial bottom line for legal construction"

"Once there is no such bottom line"

"The criminal law system and social moral and ethical system of our human society will collapse."

"This productThe consequences will be horrific and horrific"

"Give me an example"

"For example, in a hospital, there are exactly five people who need to be rescued. Their hearts, livers, spleens, lungs and kidneys are all damaged."

"At this time, you happened to be passing by. You are strong and vigorous. You look like a good organ provider."

"So the doctor said to you, young man, sacrifice your life to bring happiness to millions of families."

"Then the hospital will remove your organs on the spot and use them to save people."

"Do you think this is scary?"

Bai Xiaotu felt cold all over after hearing this example, and quickly replied

"Of course it's scary!

Ye Qiu:"Is this a crime?"

Bai Xiaotu:"Of course!"

Ye Qiu:"Should it be banned?"

Bai Xiaotu:"Of course!""............................................

Hear Ye Qiu's question and answer to Bai Xiaotu.

Netizens suddenly realized it and completely understood it

"What the anchor said makes sense! I finally understand! This is what everyone calls equality!"

"right! I just said that I just felt like something was wrong! We are all human beings, not goods, so why should we let others die casually?"

"That's right! All lives are equal! There is no such thing as high or low! Let alone substitution and compensation!"

"What Attorney Ye said was really good. I have been practicing law for more than ten years and no one has ever explained it so clearly!"

"And the examples are also simple and easy to understand, so people can understand it immediately!"

"Ahem, this example is a bit chilling. What a wonderful organ provider, just like a walking vending machine!"

"Hahaha, what Lawyer Ye said is scary but very reasonable."

"By the way, how should we solve the tram problem?"

"Don't worry. Is there really an answer to this difficult problem?"

"Just ask Lawyer Ye!"

"What if it can?"

Netizens discussed for a while.

The topic returned to Ye Qiu.

Bai Xiaotu also asked out of curiosity.

"Lawyer Ye, if it were you, how would you solve the tram problem?"

Ye Qiu smiled when he saw this.

"How to deal with it?"

"Of course it must be resolved legally"..........................................

Once you say this.

Netizens are a little confused

"Doesn’t it mean that it is not an emergency evacuation?"

"How can this be solved legally?"

"The law is not limited to emergency measures!"

"I'm so confused, I don't understand it at all! Listen to Lawyer Ye!"

Bai Xiaotu had some guesses, but he didn't know clearly. Then he asked curiously

"Lawyer Ye, can the law really solve this problem?"

Ye Qiu chuckled and said

"why not?"

"Let me ask you first, why are six people tied to the railroad tracks?"

"Who tied it? is it you?"

Bai Xiaotu was startled when he heard this and said

"Of course not me!"

"Who is that?"

"Yes, it was the person who created the trolley problem!"

Ye Qiu smiled and nodded.

"That's it"

"This question is full of traps"

"And in the final analysis, everything is the questioner’s problem"

"In order to create a problem, he kidnapped six people, which involved the crime of kidnapping"

"At the same time, he subjectively deliberately wanted one of the six people to die, which is suspected of intentional homicide."

"Then, knowing that the tram was coming, he tied up people on the tracks, which caused serious harm to the operation of the tram and the safety of drivers and passengers. This is suspected of serious endangerment of public safety."

"Also, why are you controlling the direction? Have you been brainwashed? Or was he threatened? Or was it simply being forcibly controlled? Why didn't you call the police? Or not leave?"

"Based on these circumstances, he is suspected of illegal detention, instigating others to commit criminal acts, etc."

"I won’t mention too many. Now count them. How many sins are there? All of them are major crimes that can lead to the death penalty."

"Obviously, society is extremely harmful and even has anti-social and anti-human tendencies."

"For an outlaw of this level, killing a lot of people is probably commonplace."

"So instead of letting the country kill him quickly, why not keep him alive for the New Year?"..........................................

Ye Qiu said this.

Netizens who just fell into the logic trap felt enlightened!

And get excited!

"Ha ha ha ha! As expected of Lawyer Ye! This idea is really wrong!"

"Bird food is harmful! If you ask a question, I will punish you with several capital crimes! Just asking you if you are afraid!"

"Lawyer Ye is right, if anyone asks me this kind of trap question in the future, I will call the police directly! Why don't we arrest and keep this kind of lawless maniac for the Chinese New Year?"

"askquestion? I will deal with the person who asked the question directly! This is called solving the problem from the root!"

"Hahaha! The anchor is really awesome. I recognize that you are the most valuable person on earth!"

"......"

"......"

I didn’t watch the netizens’ hilarious comments.

Ye Qiu smiled and then added

"By the way, classmate Xiaobai"

"In this case, if you did not completely lose your personal freedom and then pressed the switch, causing the death of others,"

"Then, not only does it not constitute an emergency evacuation, but it also commits the crime of coercion and murder."

"Generally, the highest penalty for accomplices of murderers is the death penalty."

Magic City Politics and Law.

In the girls' dormitory.

Bai Xiaotu exclaimed.

The mountains and rivers shook with her slender figure.

The scenery was alluring for a moment.

"Lawyer Ye, please say no!"

"I'm just giving you an example!"

"You are not really an accomplice!"..........................

In the live broadcast room.

Netizens laughed

"Ha ha! This young lady is so miserable, she almost got sentenced to death for asking a question!"

"After all, this is a live broadcast room for outlaws. It makes sense if you don’t try to get some jail time when you come in!"

"Didn’t Professor Zhang San just come back after being charged?!"

"Hahaha! Makes sense!"

Ye Qiu just drank the water leisurely and said with a smile.

"So Xiaobai, now you understand how to solve this problem, right?"

Bai Xiaotu nodded repeatedly and said

"I know, Lawyer Ye!"

"If this happens!"

"Definitely call the police as soon as possible!"

"Let the law punish criminals!"

"Rather than infringing on the legitimate rights and interests of others!"

Ye Qiu smiled slightly, put down the water glass, and said

"good"

"This is the meaning of the existence of law"

"This is also the direction that our country’s legal construction has been working towards."

"While effectively punishing illegal crimes, the various rights and interests of the people should be protected to the greatest extent."

Hearing Ye Qiu's words,

Bai Xiaotu admired Ye Qiu even more.

Ye Qiu's logic was simply outstanding and perfect!

"Lawyer Ye is really amazing!"

"Grandpa is right!"

"Only he can solve those things!"

"Moreover, if you study with him, you will definitely learn a lot in the red circle!"

Bai Xiaotu's eyes sparkled.

Her clear eyes became brighter and brighter.....................................................

PS: The fourth update is coming