If you are asked to popularize the law, will you sentence the judge to ten years?

The scene of the trial.

The three judges re-entered the court.

On the judgment seat.

Zhang Lan glanced at the entire audience.

Banging the gavel and saying

"The whole place was silent!"

"The court is now back in session!"

The court gradually became quiet.

Everyone looked at the trial seat.

But everyone's mentality was different.

At the lawyer's seat,

Ye Qiu looked calm. He looked at the trial seat calmly.

His actions.

Depends on the attitude of the presiding judge.

In the dock,

Pan Yongyi felt heavy. He was not really looking forward to the presiding judge's support. He could only take one step at a time. The prosecutor's seat. Liu Jingchun was very curious. The main accusation of the prosecutor was Gong Changwei insulted and slandered. Now Gong Changwei has been taken out. Then the task is basically completed. Next, you can enjoy the head-banging between Ye Qiu and the presiding judge. Commonly known as, eating melon. On the court. Feel it. Everyone's gaze, especially Ye Qiu's indifferent gaze, made Zhang Lan feel solemn for a moment. In this trial, she must have something she can bring to the table. That is: to prove her correctness, even if it is only part of it. Otherwise, the face may come. It was difficult for her to explain. But it was okay. She carefully studied the subway's materials. Although the subway's faults were there, they were not serious. They could not be compared with Gong Changwei and others. And the most important thing was Yes. There is no monitoring by the subway. Yes. No. Rather than deletion. This means that at this link, not to mention Ye Qiu, even the top law enforcement officers cannot have the most critical direct evidence. Then, the space for legal interpretation will be infinitely inclined to the discretion of the presiding judge. That is, as long as it complies with certain laws, Zhang Lan can interpret it in any way. No matter what Ye Qiu says makes sense, he must listen to her. Even the Supreme Court can't find fault. There is another point. Zhang Lan feels that both Gong Changwei and Cai Jing have been sentenced to defeat. This is equivalent to satisfying Ye Qiu's main demand. There is no reason for Ye Qiu to forcefully cause trouble at this stage. Right? Thinking of this, Zhang Lan calmed down slightly. Then she knocked the gavel and said

"Regarding the plaintiff Fang Dengzhong’s accusation that the defendant Fang Jindu Metro Operation Company destroyed his reputation, restricted his freedom, and refused to provide evidence, etc."

"Does the defendant have anything to explain?"

In the dock.

Pan Yongyi stood up.

He straightened his suit a little.

Then he picked up a piece of information and said

"Chief Judge, we will explain."

"The first point"

"Regarding what the other party's lawyer said, we have damaged the reputation of the plaintiff Deng Zhong. We do not understand and do not accept this."

"Because the subway operator is a third party, there was no interest relationship between the subway operator, Gong Changwei and Deng Zhong at the time of the incident."

"After the incident, the Metro did not make any comments or comments on the relevant incident."

"Therefore, the accusation that we have damaged the reputation of the plaintiff is groundless."

"Second point"

"It is also a false accusation that we have restricted the personal freedom of the plaintiff."

"Because subway personnel fully comply with relevant regulations during their work."

"Moreover, the plaintiff has free will to cooperate, and we are not restricting the freedom of the other party."

"The relevant specific processes are already included in the materials we provide."

"Ask the presiding judge to review it and make a reasonable determination"

"The third point"

"Regarding the refusal to provide evidence, we don’t quite understand what the other party’s lawyer is referring to."

"Because the subway is very cooperative with the investigations of law enforcement agencies and prosecutors."

"This is reflected in the prosecutor's records"

"Presiding Judge, we have finished our statement."

On the trial bench.

Zhang Lan took a look at the materials and said

"Does the plaintiff have any objections?"

"We have objections"

"State your objection."

Ye Qiu glanced at the defendant's seat.

Pan Yongyi instantly felt his scalp tightening.

Even if Ye Qiu didn't speak, he could instinctively feel nervous.

This was the oppression from the only lawyer in Daxia.

Ye Qiu just It was just a casual glance.

I didn’t expect Pan Yongyi to be so nervous.

But even if he knew, he didn’t care.

At this time, he withdrew his gaze, pulled out a piece of material and said

"We do not accept the defendant’s explanation."

"Because the defendant deliberately avoided important matters and confused the relevant factual findings."

"What we allege is that the other party’s staff conducted humiliating law enforcement against our client in public places."

"The result was that our client Deng Zhong’s personal reputation, personality, dignity, and public image were damaged."

"That is: when Gong Changwei slandered our client Deng Zhong for secretly filming, the subway administrator stood by Gong Changwei regardless of right or wrong."

"They took Deng Zhong off the subway by holding his arm and other controls, and asked Deng Zhong to cooperate with the inspection in the crowded subway aisle.

"Our client, Deng Zhong, could only choose to compromise under the strong request of the other party, that is: to carry out the so-called self-certification of innocence with independent will.]"

The whole process lasted for half an hour, causing our client to suffer humiliation."

"This has seriously violated the reputation, image and personal dignity of our client."

"also"

"During the half-hour inspection"

"Our client pointed out more than once that he did not take secret photos"

"At the same time, the subway authorities did not detect the candid photos."

"So he should be let go"

"Or handle the alarm"

"However, they were all stopped by the subway party and Gong Changwei."

"This is obviously a restriction on the personal freedom of our client"

"A serious infringement of the legitimate rights and interests of our client."

Hearing Ye Qiu's words,

Pan Yongyi was shocked.

Ye Qiu's defense was as sharp as ever.

But he was not unable to deal with it, and quickly raised his hand to interrupt.

"We disagree with the other party’s lawyer’s statement

"First of all, our explanation is based on facts, rather than avoiding the important and confusing the factual basis!"

"Please ask the opposing lawyer not to exaggerate at will, let alone to blame!"

"Then"

"Regarding the so-called insulting law enforcement"

"We are certain that there is no such thing"

"Because in the conflict of events at that time"

"After Gong Changwei and Deng Zhong almost had a physical conflict,"

"In order to prevent the intensification and escalation of conflicts, administrators"

"Certain measures were taken to prevent"

"This blocking behavior is not the so-called blocking of Deng Zhong."

"But he just touched Deng Zhong's hand and quickly let go."

"Similarly, the matter of getting off the train at Dengzhong was resolved through negotiation after being asked by the subway administrator."

"Rather than the so-called forcibly getting off the car"

"in addition"

"Check is not in the aisle"

"But the subway conducts it in the security department."

"And during the process, it was Deng Zhong who took off his shoes to cooperate with the inspection."

"There was no compulsory behavior by subway personnel from beginning to end."

"There is no such thing as humiliating law enforcement or restricting Deng Zhong’s personal freedom."

"The reason why Deng Zhong checked for half an hour was because he had a dispute with Gong Changwei and therefore did not leave."

"Finally, we need to emphasize that it was already very late when the incident happened."

"There were not many passengers on the subway or at the subway station, so we did not harm Deng Zhong's reputation and image in public."

Pan Yongyi's defense was very clever.

He emphasized from beginning to end that the parties involved were voluntary.

But the Metro just acted in accordance with the regulations.

There is no explanation. (To read Baoshuang novels, go to Feilu Novel Network!)

Just blame it on Gong Changwei.

After this set, the subway party was basically picked clean.

Therefore, Pan Yongyi gradually gained some confidence, looked at Ye Qiu and said

"In summary"

"We do not constitute insulting law enforcement or illegal restriction of personal freedom."

"In addition, the opposing lawyer needs to be reminded that in our country’s judicial practice, whoever advocates is the one who gives evidence."

"If the other party's lawyer insists that we have carried out humiliating law enforcement and restricted personal freedom, then please provide evidence!"

"Otherwise, it will be regarded as a false accusation against us, and we have the right to pursue relevant legal responsibilities!"

Seeing Pan Yongyi's very aggressive defense.

At the trial,

Zhang Lan nodded slightly.

Pan Yongyi is worthy of being the company's agent.

Much better than Cai Jing and Gong Changwei's performance.

In this way, Ye Qiu has nothing to argue with. space.

Pan Yongyi’s defense can be said to be in place, and it is impossible to overturn it without evidence.[]

But the next moment.

Ye Qiuyun's gentle voice sounded, but Zhanglan fell silent.

"In justice, the basic logic is that whoever advocates must provide evidence."

"But there is one point in a civil complaint that does not require proof, and that is common sense"

"Since the other party claimsTiefang did not engage in humiliating law enforcement or illegal restrictions on personal freedoms"

"Then I would like to ask the opposing lawyer a few questions." first"

"The reason for inspection by subway personnel"

"It was our client who was caught wearing a luminous candid camera device on Gong Chang's quality control shoes."

"In fact, it is just a reflective metal decorative sheet on the upper. It is very simple and convenient to check and confirm the metal sheet on the upper."

"Then why does our client need to take off his shoes and socks for inspection? And the inspection takes up to half an hour?"

"Doesn't this behavior itself violate public order and good customs, and is an insult to one's personality?"

"Secondly"

"Subway personnel themselves do not have the right to inspect"

"So, why can he conduct a half-hour inspection on our client before the law enforcement officers arrive?"

"Does the opposing lawyer think this is common sense?"

"Or do you have other explanations?"

Facing Ye Qiu's question,

Pan Yongyi also changed his color.

He opened his lips. He wanted to say something, but in the end he was speechless.

He couldn't explain it at all.

Ye Qiu was not surprised by this. Therefore, he did not wait for Pan Yongyi's answer. Instead

, he started from Bai Xiao Tu took the two materials in his hand and said unhurriedly

"This is a video clip taken by passers-by in a subway car at the time"

"From the perspective of passers-by, it can be clearly seen that when the subway staff asked Deng Zhong to get off the train,"

"In the carriage, most people cast strange looks, and one girl said to her cell phone,"I ate a big melon, and an uncle on the subway was caught secretly filming me."......]if"

"Moreover, it is clearly visible in this video that there are not many people in the carriage, which is inconsistent with the statement expressed by the other party’s lawyer that there are very few people on the subway."

"Obviously, the subway's behavior of siding with Gong Changwei regardless of the facts has affected the public image and personal dignity of our client."

"second material"

"It’s the relevant passerby’s testimony we obtained."

"They all agreed that they had seen a man standing with his back against the wall in the subway aisle that day."

"Next to him was a subway officer and a woman who were searching, scolding, etc."

"At that time, there were many passers-by who planned to take pictures, but were stopped by other subway staff."

"Clearly, the other party lied about key facts involving insults to law enforcement."

Ye Qiu's calm voice fell.

The whole audience was stunned for a moment.

Good guy!

You even investigated passers-by?

Is there anything else you haven't prepared?

Pan Yongyi also felt his scalp numb.

Ye Qiu's preparations are so thorough!

It's just like cheating!

It's too outrageous!

But it's okay.

What Ye Qiu provided was a weak basis such as testimony.

There was no strong evidence like key videos.

In this case, it was not impossible to refute.

So Pan Yongyi quickly adjusted Feeling better

"We do not agree with the other party’s lawyer’s statement"

"Because of the common sense mentioned by the other party’s lawyer and the relevant materials provided"

"All have certain one-sidedness and are not enough to be used as valid evidence."

"Unless a comprehensive and complete video of what happened can be provided"

"Otherwise it is not enough to accuse us."

Hearing Pan Yongyi's words.

At the trial table,

Zhang Lan nodded slightly.

This subway operation lawyer really has something, much better than Cai Jing and Gong Changwei.

As long as she cooperates a little, Ye Qiu will definitely not be able to win..

At the lawyer's table.

Ye Qiu was still calm and composed.

"about this point"

"It is our accusation that the defendant refused to provide evidence."

"Because the complete surveillance video should be in your company's hands"

"However, your company refused to provide surveillance video during the investigation process."

Hearing Ye Qiu's words.

Not only was Pan Yongyi not anxious, his eyes even lit up.

Ye Qiu finally fell into his trap!

"Allegation about this"

"We also do not accept it"

"Because we are not unwilling to provide evidence of surveillance video"

"Instead, no monitoring equipment was installed in the area related to the incident."

"Therefore, the relevant video cannot be provided at all."

You want surveillance video?

Let us slap you in the face?

Then you are overthinking!

Not only will they not provide surveillance video!

They can even use it to dismiss all your accusations!

There is no video!

What you said!

It can never be proven!

However, at this moment,

Ye Qiu was not surprised at all when he heard this.

Instead, he smiled meaningfully.

He looked at Pan Yongyi, who was quite proud at this time, and asked

"I would like to ask the defendant's lawyer, are you sure there is no surveillance installed?"

Looking at Ye Qiu's strange smile.

Although Pan Yongyi felt that he was in an advantage, he still couldn't help but feel nervous.

What is Ye Qiu planning?

He thought quickly in his mind.

He didn't find anything.

But he was still vigilant..Finally,

Pan Yongyi cautiously replied

"This section of road is not monitored"

"Because it has been damaged before"

"The new surveillance probes have not been installed yet."

Such a reason should be impeccable.

But the next moment,

Pan Yongyi's expression changed.

I saw the corners of Ye Qiu's mouth slightly raised, and he spoke in a calm tone.

What he said was like thunder on the ground, exploding throughout the court hearing.

"According to the anti-terrorism law implemented in our country in 2016,"

"Article 32 clearly stipulates"

"The management unit of key targets should establish a public security video image information system, and the retention period of the collected video image information shall not be less than ninety days."

"At the same time, management systems such as system duty monitoring, information storage and use, and operation and maintenance must be established to ensure the normal operation of relevant systems."

"The places that must be fulfilled include: administrative agencies, banking institutions, large urban event venues, airports, railway stations, urban rail transit stations and other key targets."

The words fell.

The whole audience was stunned.

???

Damn it!

Anti-terrorism law!

How can this be related?!

What kind of genius defense angle is this!

Outside the court. In the imperial capital.

A group directly under the central government.

Several groups The officers looked at each other.

Good guy!

Let you accuse the subway!

Did you go directly to the anti-terrorism law?!

You are too fierce, right!.